Vol 5 Chapter 18: Unique scenery
"No," Lucian admitted frankly.
Hathaway was silent for a while, and seemed to be organizing the language: "I think the comments you give are too high, which will make the Arcanist dreamy and detached from reality, although the electronic wave has been applied to the new alchemy model. Here, it is possible to derive some of the imposed quantization conditions naturally, but to evaluate such a hypothesis without any experiments and signs to guide it, do not use a serious and pragmatic arcane atmosphere to develop. "
She was a bit messy, but Lucian still barely understood. Because treating electrons as waves can solve part of the current new alchemy, her assumptions about Dieppe were not conservative and stubborn as imagined. After a certain psychological preparation, after all, for her, the perfection of new alchemy is more important, and it is her future direction.
In addition, she used the term “waves” to describe electrons, not “electrons are waves”. Obviously, she attributed the problem to the special properties of some particles, just like the particle theory proponents' interpretation of light quantum diffraction and interference images— Although these conjectures are full of contradictions and none have been valued, it does not prevent Hathaway from referring to similar ideas.
What she really wants to refute is the comment given by Lucian, which is too high. It must be known that any previously unbelievably bold assumption was related to the discovery of certain problems and loopholes, such as Lucian's The light quantum hypothesis is based on the theory that wave theory cannot explain the photoelectric effect.
And this time Dieppe ’s hypothesis is purely a product of a broad mindset, pushing the wave-particle duality of light to all microscopic particles, but whether or not light is a particle has to be questioned, and there is no indication that this is not How can it be rashly and blindly promoted in the particle world due to its unique nature?
Most importantly, this hypothesis just seems to solve the problem of the new alchemy, and it does not explain the photoelectric effect as clearly as the light quantum hypothesis. It is consistent with all the current experimental results even without precise experiments. So, for this The assumption that Hathaway thinks that Lucian should not be evaluated so high will allow other arcanists to put forward completely divergent and utopian hypotheses specifically for theories without any previous problems, allowing rigorous exploration, practical research, and careful application of Austrian The ethos of art was completely destroyed.
In short, she thinks that Lucien's beautiful words about Dieppe's hypothesis will cause a trend of speculative arcane research.
Hathaway's language skills were well understood by all the members of the highest jury present. Oliver was worried that Lucien did not understand the point. He also added: "If you evaluate Diepp's unfounded thesis like this, it will make other Austrian The surgeon thinks that there are opportunities, because without the discovery of any problems, he can blame a classic theory for errors, and then start from this fantasy, and get a rigorous deduction process by mathematical methods. As for the ridiculous results, they do n’t It's okay. "
"For example, I can directly accuse you of being a church spy without the evidence. With this premise, I can rely on what you have done, and then use strict but selective derivation to prove that you have published a subversive paper. It is to blast off the heads of more magicians and even directly kill the members of our highest jury to achieve the goal of destroying the magic council. Don't you think this is ridiculous? We should encourage such behavior? "
Lucien said very seriously: "I got some inspiration from the hypothesis that electrons are waves. I seem to see the dawn of solving the problem of new alchemy. This gives such a high evaluation. If this hypothesis can solve the problem of new alchemy, , And conversely, it also confirmed it. "
而且 "And since photons can have volatility, why can't electrons? Neutrons can't? Protons can't? In the microscopic field, this is a relatively traceable assumption, not pure fantasy."
In the discussion of arcane art, Lucian is a man with his own insistence. He cannot admit that he is too reckless because of the accusations of the two great arcanists. The professionalism and authoritativeness of making your own comments are unfair, and it is also unfair to Dieppe's efforts.
Even if I have n’t done experiments to confirm it, I will have the same insistence. It is necessary to make myself give this comment. However, if you really point out a loophole or refute the experimental results, you are not Stubborn person.
"When was light recognized as a particle?" Vicente, a pale middle-aged man in a black cloak, said coldly, the dark red flames in his eyes beating very fiercely.
Hathaway looked at the ghost who dominated: "Whether you admit it or not, the photoelectric effect and the Brook scattering experiment are all there, clearly showing everything."
"But I think there may be explanations for fluctuations such as scattering experiments, such as ..." Oliver said his own ideas to build special waves that can show particleness.
Douglas frowned: "No experiment or theory can support your ideas yet."
"This may not be a direction," Brook said concisely.
Uh ...
For a while, due to the dispute between wave theory and particle theory, the entire Supreme Jury meeting room became very noisy, and gradually, as the quarrel deepened, they even experienced emotional fluctuations.
"Build your special complex wave before you talk about it, Oliver." When Claus spoke, there seemed to be countless light spots behind his back, forming different illusions of alchemy things. There were golems, puppets, and floating cities. There are alchemy fortresses, there are magic steam trains ...
Oliver shook his finger: "No matter how you look at it, this is also a way to explain the photoelectric effect and the Brook scattering experiment. And, before discussing my question, you better review the theory of particles. Maybe there have never been any particles. They are all It's a special manifestation of waves. "
毁 One after another, devastating scenes around him turned out, staining the conference room with a layer of doom.
"If the particles are all waves, are the elements composed of these microscopic particles waves? Are the lives of these elements waves? More precisely, are we waves?" Vicente did not agree with Oliver on this inference, He is an authority on the human body and soul, and it is hard to believe that the body is a wave? How could a body with a solid touch be a wave?
Lu Anning's everlasting black tombstones seemed to grow one after another on the carpet of the conference room, and silent death enveloped everything.
Oliver waved his hand, signaled that his sentence was not precise enough, and reiterated: "To be honest, although I admire the assumption of Dieppe, I also want to give him a high evaluation of the corner of the world, but at least I have so far Don't believe electrons will be waves. "
一边 He said, while using magic, he directly constructed a picture of electronic movement in the cloud room. The pale fog droplets constituted a wonderful electronic trajectory, full of fantasy and shocking taste.
"The electron with such an obvious particle trajectory, for the time being, I am not so bold to believe that it is a wave, but since Lucien agreed with Dieppe's hypothesis, does it also mean that he agrees that the essence of light is wave?" At the same time, Oliver set his sights on Lucian.
He is using Lucian's comment to attack his own quantum theory of light.
"I said, maybe the electrons can show volatility in special cases, such as when bound to the nucleus.
”Hathaway stood at Lucian's camp again at this time.
Helen is a rare legendary magician who has no projection of the cognitive world. She has been listening quietly to the dispute between wave theory supporters and particle theory supporters. At this time, she could not help but interjected: "Actually, the hypothesis of light is confirmed After that, I was very confused. Why does light have both volatility and particles? Should it really be viewed at a higher level, as Evans said? "
"Can be explained from the wave theory ..." Oliver once again emphasized that his opinion can be a great Arcanist, and it is necessary to insist.
Seeing that the two parties would start a "frank and friendly conversation" again, Douglas quickly gestured for the visions in their quiet conference room to disappear suddenly, and changed from hell-like scenes back to the real world.
"The confrontation between wave theory and particle theory has been going on for a long time, there is no need to delay today's time. Since Lucian insists that his comments are not a problem in themselves and are not the result of the thesis review, then it seems that there is no need to discuss it?" Douglas looked around the crowd A glance.
利 Oliver nodded softly: "I ask one more, I believe everyone is equally curious, Lucian, in your mind, is light a wave or a particle?"
还有 "Also, are electrons waves or particles?" Vicente added coldly.
He Hathaway, Helen and others also looked at Lucien, quite curious about his true arcane position.
Since the appearance of visions, Lucien has been quietly watching this situation that is quite different from any scene. This is a unique scenery that can only appear when the highest jury meets.
At this time, hearing their questions and feeling the eyes of everyone, Lucian did not refuse to answer, but looked at the abnormal teacher with a little worry, and seriously asked: "What is a wave? What is a particle?"
Yep? The members present were at least the Arcanist of the Nine Rings, and did not expect that Lucien would ask the most basic concepts, and he was a little stunned for a moment.
"Luxion, this is not the time to lecture, although your nickname is Professor." Oliver consciously said humorously.
There are only two dark red flames in Vicente's eyes, and only thin skin with bones on his face makes it difficult to see his true emotions: "The definition of waves and particles is in the book of basic arcane It was mentioned that everyone's time is precious, and if you don't want to answer, keep silent. "
"Wave is a phenomenon. It was originally a definition summarized from various fluctuations in nature and used in the study of arcane. The specific definition is ..." Hathaway did not care about Vicente, and roughly defined the definition of waves and particles. Speaking.
Kushiro smiled: "It is obvious that the definition of waves and particles comes from us, and from our experience of the real world that can be directly observed."
"What's wrong with this?" Bruker crossed his fingers against his chin, and seemed to be guessing.
Douglas, the prophets Begner, and Hathaway seemed to remember something, each with a thoughtful expression. The difference was that Hathaway's expression was almost unchanged. It would be difficult to detect without a closer look, and the storm dominated Fernando would still be the same as before. Silent attitude.
Baluchien didn't answer directly, but looked at the crowd: "If you don't find it a waste of time, I want to tell a story first."
"No problem." Oliver has always been forgiving of the story.
Since he speaks, other members of the Supreme Jury will naturally not object to such trivial matters, and they believe that Lucian is definitely not a random storytelling to persuade everyone, and certainly has his own intentions. Besides, the previous quarrels and questions were based on The non-arc above arcane is specifically aimed at Lucian, can clear the question, what does it matter to tell a story? It's OK to talk about ten!
"A king once received a dragon that had just died, and was very pleased to put it as a symbol of his heroism outside the palace so that every passing noble and civilian could see it." Lucian voice Gently recounted, "One day, a group of blind people who did not know about the dragon heard about it, and wondered what the dragon looked like, so they went outside the palace and stroked the dragon's body."
I heard a group of blind people trying to figure out the dragon by "touching" the members of the relatively cheerful top jury, such as Oliver and Claus, all smiled, while others were guessing the result.
Baluchian continued to say, "A blind man touched the wings of a dragon with the help of a soldier, and immediately said happily, 'The dragon is a terrifying big bat!'"
‘" No, the dragon is a big lizard! "Another blind man who touched the scales of the dragon retorted loudly. Before he blinded his eyes, he once caught a lizard and touched its scales."
When hearing the words of the first blind man, most of the members of the highest judging panel showed a smile, but after the second blind man's answer appeared, they all became dignified. Douglas, Hathaway, etc. had some speculation and psychology. The preparer nodded slightly.
"I don't want to say more about the rest of the blind. I just want to ask, is the dragon a big bat or a lizard?"
"Neither." Helen probably knew what Lucian meant, but answered it seriously.
Kushiro smiled, "So to me, light and electrons are neither waves nor particles. The only thing that can be confirmed is that they belong to matter. Of course, I prefer to use particles to call them."
"Neither waves nor particles?" Oliver frowned slightly. "Do you want to say that they are actually something else?"
Lucian looked around the conference room: "We can't directly see the electromagnetic waves including visible light, nor can we directly see the particles in the microscopic field. Our research on these fields is like blind people, so we can only rely on Observable phenomena should not blindly impose on them the definitions and concepts of past experience. "
"Taking light as an example, we can describe it this way without loading it with the concept of waves or particles in advance. This material shows obvious fluctuations, and also has obvious particle properties. What is the frequency range? What is the velocity in various media? As for what a substance with these properties is called, that is not the point. It can be defined as anything. As for why it shows volatility or granularity, respectively, volatility and granularity The way in which it is combined is what we need to further study, and the experimental results and real phenomena must prevail. "
"The reason why we argue endlessly is to apply rigidly the concepts and definitions of the past in the microscopic field and to the places closest to the real world. I once said that our experience will deceive us, and this is the manifestation. First, such deception is not only reflected in research, but also in our interactions with others. "
Speaking of this, Lucian looked around the members of the top jury with different expressions again and solemnly:
只有 "Only by learning to temporarily abandon the original concept and firmly based on current phenomena and experimental results, can we 'see' the reality of this world in this microworld."
After Balusian's words were spoken, weird silence appeared in the conference room, each of them thinking differently.
"But there is no original concept to take what is used to study the micro world, and the experimental results and phenomena also need to be processed and structured into a system." Oliver agreed, but more questioned.
Kushiro simply said: "Mathematical tools."
"I don't know what it is, how do I know what mathematical tools are needed?" Vicente didn't agree.
"The experimental results that can be directly observed can apply the previous concepts and definitions, but not the ones that are not directly observed, but can be deduced from the experimental results, or guesses and hypotheses can be put forward, and then confirmed by rigorous experiments.
”Lucian elaborated his own point of view, which was gradually formed and solidified by the influence of strange things such as magic, soul, and feedback in the real world and the study of quantum theory.
所以 "So guessing that electrons are waves? But there hasn't been rigorous experimental confirmation." Vicente continued, and after a long walk, the topic returned to the original.
Douglas nodded softly: "I think Lucian makes some sense. We see something because light reflects into our eyes. Magnifying magic is also based on the same optical principles. But light will react with electrons. It will Let it appear 'transition', that is, change its state, so at least so far, it is difficult for us to think of a way to directly observe the microworld, and we can only rely on the results of various experiments to conclude hypotheses or interpretations from induction, and when hypotheses or interpretations , We cannot substitute too many original concepts, which will constrain our thoughts and blind our hearts. "
"But in any case, directly guessing whether the electron is a wave or it is too far away from reality. At least the current experimental results show no sign of this, without exception, it shows particle." Oliver shook his head, and Hathaway and others slightly. Nodding, agreeing with him, at least the granularity is the obvious experimental result, and it is difficult for people to associate the volatility from that clear trajectory.
However, they also initially accepted that in arcane research, in the microcosm, they cannot blindly substitute the original concept.
"Can you give up the original concept to see the reality of the world?" Bruker sighed with a sigh. "We can learn arcane art from an early age. We accept all kinds of definitions and concepts. We may accidentally substitute the original concepts in our research. I do n’t know, and sometimes, introducing the original concept will make things easier. "
Douglas looked at the pocket watch and said, "It's getting late, Lucian also expressed his views, and you can exchange them in private."
"Well, I will try to reconstruct the new alchemy model with the concept of electron waves, and give its wave function to see if it can solve the problem to verify this hypothesis." Brook was very interested in this direction and seemed to find it Reshape the way you know the world.
Oliver also nodded: "I will also put my ideas into the concept of electronic waves, try to build its wave function, and hope to gain something."
Hathaway didn't express anything. When she could not speak, she always said nothing.
And "Desperate Soul" Vicente dominated the storm with a mockery: "Old pervert, why haven't you talked? Is it because you are your own student that you don't want to growl in front of us? This is not like arcane art You who are very persistent in the field of truth. "
这么 He said so, the other members of the top jury only came to their senses, and the Storm Lord never spoke! You should know that when such controversy happened in the past, the conference room must be dominated by lightning, thunder, torrential rain, and roaring quake. Is it so abnormal today?
The storm dominated Fernando as if suppressing something. After looking at Vicente, he glared at Lucian: "Take it out, they should be able to withstand this shock."
"Come out?" Lucian pretended to be stupid.
"What to come up with?" The other top jury members were full of questions.
Fernando growled violently: "When you give a comment, I know you have completed the experiment! Take it out and let us see what is called the reality of the world! Look at what is giving up the original concept!"
"Do you think we can't afford such a shock? Especially in unknown areas!"
Completed the experiment? Oliver, Claus and others looked at Lucian in amazement. Is it really finished? Doesn't Lucian's attitude mean ... how is this possible?
连 Even the legendary magicians with indifferent expressions such as Hathaway and Helen also showed a little shock and surprise, which made them full of life, as if only flesh and blood were now available.
Douglas looked at Lucian solemnly: "If it is done, take it out, and the people sitting here will not be so narrow and stubborn."
He added to his mind that most of them were supporters of the wave theory, and a small part was psychologically prepared because of this assumption.
Balussian looked at them silently, got a consistent prostration, took a deep breath, took out a large single crystal, and arranged the magic array at hand, so that the image could be directly displayed.
Brook didn't speak, raised his hand, and directly emitted a stream of electrons.
Time seems to be solidified, with unusual depression and silence. Before long, the magic array lights up and a classic picture like X-ray diffraction pattern appears!
图案 In the eyes of everyone, this pattern is so familiar, so dreamy, but so shocking, so incredible!
"This ..." I don't know how many inner self-talks came out unconsciously Boom!
Countless flashes of lightning dance, thunder rushes, black storm shrouds the sky;
黑色 The black magnetic field around it is distorted, and the invisible electromagnetic wave is abnormally disordered;
Stars emerged, emitting a bright light, distorting the surrounding space, hanging down the gravitation;
White, black, gold, silver, a little element condensed into a sea-like tide;
In the peaceful and peaceful place of sleep, black tombstones were obliquely inserted on top of it, filled with a strong breath of death;
The black universe is vast and wide, one planet after another is annihilated, and it is caught in an endless wave of destruction;
A lot of snowflakes drifted, the temperature of the entire room dropped by a full Baidu, and there was crystal ice everywhere;
Numerous visions emerged and stirred in the conference room, forming a horror scene where light and shadow intersect, dance and death dance together!
Boom!
In the sound of illusory thunder and destruction, they turned to look at Lucien, seeing Lucien standing there, his hands in the black double-breasted long dress pockets, and the voice was repeated in a low voice. speak:
"Give up the original concept in order to see the reality of the world."
Send two chapters, please recommend tickets on Monday!
(To be continued, "This text is provided by the breaking dawn update group @w 苏 颜". If you like this work, you are welcome to go to (m) to vote for recommendations and monthly tickets. Your support is my greatest motivation.)